Responding to the NEETs Crisis with wisdom and compassion
Over the last couple of days I’ve been reading Alan Milburn’s review of young people and work. A number of the figures have stood out to me, but so have some of the stories young people told the review. One in particular has stayed with me.
A young person had found a job and there was a scheme intended to help them stay in it. By the time the help arrived, the job had ended. As they put it, “Access to Work came after I finished work.”[1]
Stories like that one struck me, because they highlight something which is easily missed in the debate about welfare reform: here was a young person who had done what we ask young people to do, only to be let down by a system that failed to do what it had promised. Who is responsible for such failures? Should we make promises we can’t keep as a society? Or should we be honest about what can or cannot be done and provided?
The Milburn Review began when the former Prime Minister Keir Starmer demanded an investigation into a growing number of young people are out of education, employment or training (the so-called Neets).
Almost a million 16- to 24-year-olds are now in that position. The number receiving Disability Living Allowance or Personal Independence Payment has doubled since 2012 to more than 400,000, although some of those young people are in work and these benefits can help them stay there. Spending on the youth health and disability benefits tracked by the review rose from £1.7 billion in 2019/20 to £4.7 billion in 2025/26. The government has to take that rise seriously, and it has to ask why so many young people are struggling to find a place in work or learning in the first place.[2]
[1] Paragraph 191 of the report found at https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-a-new-settlement-for-the-next-generation/from-a-welfare-state-to-a-working-state-a-new-settlement-for-the-next-generation?utm_source=chatgpt.com#chapter-2-a-lost-generation-is-a-choice
[2] Figures taken from chapter 2 of the report
Honest conversations
I think many of us in my generation and older are baffled by the rise and prevalence of mental ill health among young people and by how much more we hear about neurodiversity. If I’m honest, I sometimes find it frustrating when I can’t make sense of what I’m seeing, and I can catch myself wondering whether some of it comes down to a lack of resilience.
And we all have our own prejudices, shaped by our own experience. I had loving parents, supportive teachers and financial help to study. I didn’t have particularly good advice about where to go to university or what work to pursue, so I followed my interests and, by God’s providence, I ended up somewhere that opened a lot of doors. My naivety cost me little, and so it would be easy for me to sit in judgement over young people today. ‘I did OK though my own endeavours and ability, so why can’t they do the same?’
But my experience working with the Children’s Commissioner for England, and later leading a charity working on behalf of children and families, is that when you listen to most young people, you begin to realise how real their difficulties are and how deep some of them go. Often their stories are complex and as perplexing and frustrating for the individual young person as they are for those seeking to help them.
But we should be able to admit that without feeling paralysed into inaction. Recognising there are things we don’t understand or can’t easily fix is no justification for letting a situation continue to develop. We need to consider what we can control, rather than what we can’t.
For example, today a degree is treated as a basic requirement for a job – it is what A-levels were in ‘’my day’. Of course, it matters that university is open to as many young people as possible. But there are assumptions behind such a statement that we need to start questioning.
The Chancellor of a world-leading university told me last year that on some of the programmes his university ran, 40% of students required support for a disability. Another lecturer told me this week that it is normal to have at least 25% of classes requiring learning support of some kind. Both thought that these numbers were unsustainable, while not wanting to close off routes to university. And if someone gets through a degree, with regular help to organise their workload, what happens when they start a job? Many employers simply will not be able to provide the same levels of support.
I think we also need to be honest with young people about what prosects some degrees open up – or don’t open up. If we encourage a young person to see a course as a route into a particular career, we owe them an honest conversation about what the work involves, what would have to change for them to do it, and whether that change is realistic. That conversation ought to start well before they finish the course, and requires honesty that we find all-too easy to avoid.
A broader view of compassion
The Milburn Review is candid about the costs involved here, and we cannot shy away from them. Modelling puts the overall annual saving at about £200 million in 2036/37, once the cost of his reforms is taken into account. That is a long time to wait for savings that in themselves will barely make an indent upon public finances.
Personally, I think it is worth investing now to improve the prospects of young people who are having a difficult start. But I also think compassion involves asking something difficult of someone because it’s in their long-term interests.
We can be reluctant to do that, in our own relationships as much as in public policy, because it’s uncomfortable and we may get it wrong. Sometimes the harder thing is to tell a young person honestly that the route they had in mind will be difficult and help them find another. Sometimes it’s to expect them to persevere when they’re ready to give up. Either takes time and knowledge: the kind of investment that can’t simply be measured in financial terms.
And Milburn proposes that a young person who can participate and persistently refuses to engage should lose a proposed Youth Allowance as a last resort.
Of course, where paid work is genuinely beyond someone’s reach, they should have financial security they can rely on. Each of us bears God’s image, whatever we’re able to earn. But I believe it’s fair to expect people to do what they reasonably can, but also to enforce consequences when they do not.
So before taking away someone’s income, I would want the state to show that it had made a suitable offer, that the help had arrived and that the young person could reasonably take it up. But if those conditions are met, and a lack of employment is indicative of rebellion rather than inability, it is right that there are consequences.
Sacrificial leadership
But the Bible does not speak only about the responsibility we have as individuals: it also has much to say about both how society and employers should support those who are struggling financially.
In Leviticus 19, God tells landowners to leave the edges of their fields and the fallen grain for people who are poor and for foreigners living among them. Similarly, Deuteronomy 24 tells the Israelites to remember that they were once slaves in Egypt. That memory is meant to change a decision a farmer makes in the middle of a working day. They could go back for the sheaf they missed. God tells them to leave it. Godly management is not solely about making the most profit: it encompasses a social responsibility, rooted in God’s character, as revealed in the history of His people.
We see an example of this in action in Ruth 2, Boaz makes space for Ruth in his field, gives her access to water, tells his workers to leave her alone and asks them to pull out extra stalks for her. Ruth, for her part, has to take the initiative and work until evening. But it costs Boaz grain he could have kept. I think that it is fair to ask employers how much of what they could keep for themselves are they prepared to give up so that someone else has a chance to get started?
My dad always ran his own business, so I grew up knowing something of how hard it can be to make a profit. I also saw him employ young people, some in their first job, who needed patient training and encouragement. That takes time, especially in a small business where the person leading the training has their own work to get through. But those young people gained experience that would serve them well wherever they went next. When I think about what gleaning might mean for an employer today, that’s the sort of thing I have in mind.
The Bible gives us grounds for expecting that kind of responsibility from people who control access to work. How much of the cost should be borne by a modern welfare state is a question we have to exercise judgement about. I do think government has a responsibility to help young people into work and to help employers give them a fair chance. In that sense I have sympathy with what ministers have described as reforming welfare in a ‘Labour way’, if that means doing the work of helping people into employment before looking to cut their benefits.
I do want us to take young people seriously enough to expect something of them. But the story of Ruth asks us to take just as seriously what’s expected of those of us who already have a field, a business or some say over how public money is spent.
And I’d start that conversation with a fairly straightforward. When a young person does their part and gets a job, what part have I played in making that possible? And if they have one, how can I help them to support them in keeping it?