Freedom of Speech

Conversion Practices Bill risks "driving out doctors" and criminalising Christian preaching

Doctor and stethoscope in hand

A former health minister has warned that the draft Conversion Practices Bill risks driving doctors out of the profession, while hundreds of church leaders have written in protest over the bill.

Med­ic­al perspective

Zubir Ahmed, who is a Labour MP and a doctor, writing in The Times newspaper said: “Some experts have even suggested that if the draft bill is not amended, it could be misused by activists as a way of targeting those clinicians who take the same cautious approach that the Cass review set out”. He warns that the safeguards for doctors and other healthcare workers are too weak, and the threshold for criminality under the new law is too low.

Ahmed said that the law risks “wading into a contested clinical space” without protections for doctors who want to follow the evidence-based approach advocated by Baroness Cass in her review of NHS gender services for children. Ahmed particularly highlighted the use of the word “abusive” in the legislation and the absence of a definition which would leave people uncertain about whether they had broken the law.

“It is not difficult to see why this lack of clarity could be particularly dangerous for those who seek to help young people without immediately affirming that they are transgender, or prescribing treatment like cross-sex hormones. A vulnerable young patient might fervently want this outcome and truly believe that it is cruel and harmful for them to be denied it… it could be misused by activists as a way of targeting those clinicians who take the same cautious approach that the Cass review set out,” he writes, adding: “We must also make sure that the clinicians who we trust to treat our young people are not pushed out of the profession by an ever more hostile environment and weak safeguards.” He concludes that “any government should be wary of the unintended impact of the laws they propose, and must listen to the evidence of the professionals on the front line.”

Chris­ti­an response

Ahmed’s comments come as the government closes its deadline for evidence on the proposed legislation. In response, over 1,300 church leaders from a range of Christian denominations have written to the equalities minister, Bridget Phillipson, to warn that the draft bill will “criminalise” Christian teaching.

The letter makes it clear that the legislation as it stand would make it a crime to preach “mainstream, historic Christian doctrine” and would target “normal, responsible Christian parenting”. Along with the leaders, the letter has also been signed by over 1,500 Christian supporters.

The letter’s signatories, which include Anglican vicars, Catholic priests, and pastors from every other major denomination, state: “We will not cease to fulfil our duty to God to teach his ways faithfully, even if an unjust law should make us criminals for doing so.” They say that conversion is a core Christian concept which has been appropriated as a label for an ill-defined offence, making it “grossly offensive to Christians”.

“Responsible Christian parents and pastors will be criminalised by the draft bill, in direct violation of human rights law on family life, freedom of speech, and freedom of religion,” the letter goes on. “We urgently request that you abandon this bill, and that you meet with us to gain a better understanding of historic Christian teaching, to avoid a disastrous legislative misstep.”

Share