Freedom of Speech

Baroness Cass cannot support Conversion Practices Bill

Conversion therapy ban protest

Baroness Hilary Cass, the author of the independent review into NHS gender services for children, has said that she cannot support the government’s draft Conversion Practices Bill.

Com­mit­tee evidence

Giving evidence before the committee considering the draft legislation, Cass said of the new bill: “Having obviously spent a long time now thinking about it, I unfortunately I don't think it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences.”

Reported by journalist Hannah Barnes on social media platform X, Cass said that she had seen the Bill only fifteen minutes before the government wanted the press statement signed off. Cass’ review into gender services said that nobody should be subjected to conversion practices, which Cass calls “abhorrent and not something anyone should condone.” Nevertheless, she has significant concerns about the legislation.

Com­plaints and con­cern for parents

Cass warns that there are no clear standards for approaching transgender issues, and that the area is highly contested. She highlights ‘malign actors’ who want to exploit young people and pursue people working in the field, calling it “a significant problem”. Those conducting “careful, exploratory work with teenagers” could be targeted with vexatious complaints and labelled as ‘conversion therapists’. She highlighted clinicians who have needed to have security with them before giving talks on the subject of gender, a situation “that’s not normal in any area of medicine.”

Baroness Cass also voiced concerns for parents, who will unavoidably be caught up in the consequences of the bill. Parents who do not agree to change a child’s pronouns, or refuse to give money to pay for breast binders or hormones, would be in reach of this proposed legislation.

Dev­il in the details

The Cass Review detailed how the role of psychological therapies are overshadowed by the debate over conversion therapy. Speaking to the committee, Cass said that she was still concerned about this, saying: “I am still concerned because unfortunately, the polarisation is worse now than when we came out with the report.”

When asked if clarity on certain points about the bill would help, Cass responded that “the devil is in the details” and she would need to see the text of any changes. Cass agreed that the bill would have a chilling effect on whistleblowing in cases such as the Tavistock Centre.

“Do you support this Bill as drafted,” asked Labour MP Naz Shah. To which Baroness Cass simply replied, “No.”

Share