CARE: Christian Action, Research and Education

Assisted Suicide
Cause menu Close menu
Protect S2
Assisted Suicide

Consultation on Assisted Dying For Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill — Guide

Scotland has a proud heritage as a caring nation. All that is being undermined by this new Bill. I'd like to invite you to stand with us as we say 'no' to assisted suicide and 'yes' to better quality end of life care.
Dr Stuart Weir Director, CARE for Scotland

Liam McArthur MSP has launched a public consultation in Scotland on proposals for a new Assisted Suicide Bill.

It's called the Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill consultation and it will run until 22 December.

The easiest way to respond is by filling in this online form directly.

Hard copy responses should be printed and sent by post to: Liam McArthur MSP, Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh, EH99 1SP. The consultation document itself can be read here.

Below, you'll find our guide to help you respond accurately and effectively. This should take approximately 5-10 minutes of your time.

Please click here to access the online consultation response form.

Con­sulta­tion Guide

Don't forget, you'll need to click on this link to open up the online consultation form. The best thing to do is to keep it open in another window and refer back to this page.

About You

Q1: make sure you tick the first box ['an individual']

Q2A-5: are self-explanatory

Your views on the proposal

Q1: We suggest selecting the 'Fully Opposed' option.

In terms of explaining the reasons for your response in the box provided, you may wish to mention some of the following points:

    • The Bill would send a signal that some lives are no longer worth living.
    • The Bill would place pressure on sick and vulnerable people to end their lives out of fear of becoming a burden.
    • The Bill would fundamentally alter the patient/doctor relationship in that there would no longer be an over-riding duty of care.
    • The Bill would lead to the normalisation of assisted suicide and contradicts society’s efforts to reduce suicide rates.
    • Parliament should not be asked to consider proposals to hasten premature death while Scotland is still in the midst of a Covid pandemic that is leading to the premature death of many Scots.

Q2: We suggest using this box to say that you do not believe legislation is required and that more investment in holistic palliative care would be the best means of achieving dignity in dying.

Q3: We suggest selecting ‘Fully opposed’. If you wish to add anything in the box, you could make the point that diagnosing a terminal illness and ensuring the decision is wholly voluntary are of necessity problematic to determine with a sufficient degree of certainty.

Q4: We suggest selecting ‘Fully opposed’.

Please use the box provided to make the point that any supposed safeguards would inevitably be eroded over time as has happened elsewhere, either in the Courts or by Parliament itself. You may also wish to point out that the number of people opting to end their lives would inevitably increase greatly has happened in other countries.

Q5: We suggest selecting ‘Fully opposed’ and using the box to state that such a body would not be required if the legislation were to be abandoned.

Q6: Express concern that conscientious objection, while vital, could be difficult to maintain over time as protections could be eroded by the Courts. The inevitable increase in cases would also place greater demand on medics to participate.

Financial Implications

Q7: We suggest selecting ‘a significant reduction in costs’. Please then use the box provided to draw attention to footnote 124 on pages 28-9 of the consultation document where it is conceded that it is cheaper to end life than to provide care. Say that you are very worried that financial pressures may cause many people to feel pressurised into considering assisted dying.


Q8: We suggest selecting ‘Negative’.

Please use the box to say that the proposals would have a negative impact on the elderly and disabled, to whom the Bill would send a signal that certain lives are no longer worth living. It is also individuals in these categories who are most likely to feel pressurised into considering assisted dying. In the absence of the Bill, such pressure would not exist.


Q9: We suggest selecting ‘No’.

Please use the box to explain that the Bill’s proposals represent the antithesis of “a strong, healthy and just society”. You may wish to draw a contrast between the proposals and the approach to the pandemic whereby the sick and elderly were in fact prioritised for care to protect their lives.


Q10: An opportunity to make any further points.

Please respond as soon as you can

To get our message across, it's vital as many people as possible respond to the consultation. Don't forget to share this page with friends and family.

The final deadline for responses is 22 December, but it's best to respond as soon as possible, while it's still fresh in your mind.

Once again, here's the online form you'll need to submit a response.

Stuart Weir
Thank you for stand­ing with us. This is a really import­ant moment in the fight to pro­tect the most vul­ner­able and cham­pi­on a bet­ter way than assisted sui­cide. Please pray Mr McAr­thur will pay atten­tion to our voices.
Stuart Weir National Director, CARE for Scotland
Scottish Parliament min

Find out more about our CARE for Scotland team

Find out more about our work in Scotland and how you can best stay informed about what's happening at the Scottish Parliament.

Find out more

Sign up for Impact Direct, and email publications

By signing up stay in touch you agree to receive emails from CARE. You can change your mailing preferences at any time either by getting in touch with CARE, or through the links on any of our emails.

Donate to CARE

Your donation to CARE enables us to continue to work towards a culture and society reflecting a better story for everyone.

We only ask you to consider giving to CARE after you have considered the needs of your family and church.

All donations are securely processed.

I want to give…

& society reflecting a better story for everyone.

At the heart of all of CARE’s work is our determination to uphold the truth that human beings made in God’s image are immensely valuable and deserve to be treated with dignity and compassion.

We want to show a better story for our culture and society, and we want to be part of shaping that in structures that we are given as citizens in the UK…

Find out more about the better story
A woman sitting with a smart phone in her lap