CARE: Christian Action, Research and Education

For what you believe
Open menu Close menu
Scottish Parl front 0
Religious Liberty

Scotland’s new Hate Crime Laws endanger free speech

1 May 2020

At the end of last week, the Scottish Government published its Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Bill. It aims to modernise, consolidate and extend existing hate crime law.

Prior to publication, the Scottish Government ran a consultation on the issue and, strikingly, the majority of responders were not supportive of hate crime laws in the first place. Most argued that the effect of such laws is that they stifle free speech and create a hierarchy of victims, where some are deemed more worthy of protection than others.

Yesno Istock 7
Majority of responses to the consultation on the new laws were opposed to hate crime laws

Prom­in­ent MSP warns new laws could endanger free speech

Now, a prominent Scottish Tory MSP, Murdo Fraser has warned that a particular provision in the legislation could cause a lot of problems. The legislation as drafted contains measures that lead to new offences of 'stirring up hatred'.

At the moment, these apply only to racial hatred, but the plan is to extend this to encompass all groups defined by reference to age, disability, religion, sexual orientation, transgender identity and variations of sex characteristics.

The crux of the issue is that it won’t be necessary to prove an ‘intent’ on the part of the accused party to stir up hatred. Rather, they would only need to prove that hatred in relation to a particular, protected characteristic, is ‘likely to be stirred up thereby’.

Could ortho­dox Chris­ti­an views be criminalised?

It's not difficult to see the issue here. For evangelical Christians, the risks of where these new laws could lead are incredibly concerning.

This is an incredibly dangerous moment in the battle for free speech. For example, under this criteria, could a Scottish pastor who held to the traditional, orthodox Christian view of marriage and sex be found guilty?

Only recently, Franklin Graham was barred from various venues across Scotland after protests over his views on sexuality.

Thankfully, the Bill does contain protections for free speech. For example, it permits discussions or criticisms of religions and of sexual conduct or practices.

Shutterstock 300750932 0 0
New hate crime laws must strike the right balance

Hate crime laws must be fair and balanced’

Yet as Murdo Fraser says, it remains to be seen whether these protections go far enough. He concludes his article by saying this:

“It is precisely because, in a free society, we need to protect people’s right to hold unpopular opinions and express them, and to say the wrong things, that legislation on hate crime needs to be fair and balanced.”
Murdo Fraser Scottish Conservative MSP

CARE’s view

At CARE we believe strongly in freedom of expression. Balancing the need to promote a civilised society with the absolute freedom to express our views, no matter how unpopular is always immensely difficult. But to compel speech goes right against the whole principle of freedom of expression. MSPs will want to consider these new laws very carefully indeed and if there is even the slightest risk to free speech, then the legislation should be redrafted or rejected entirely.

At CARE, we believe strongly in freedom of expression.
James Mildred Head of Communications

Religious Liberty

The right to freedom of religion or belief is a fundamental human right. We are campaigning to safeguard these freedoms in our society.

Find out more about the cause

Sign up for Impact Direct

We want to show a better story for our culture and society, and we want to help you be part of shaping that in structures that we are given as citizens in the UK.

Our weekly email, Impact Direct, is about helping you stay informed, up-to-date, and equipped to engage in culture and society.

Sign up now

Recent news

1993 care for life 3

Next two weeks will be crucial in the fight for life

The next two weeks are going to be critical in the fight for life. Since 1967, Great Britain has had a liberal and permissive abortion law and there has been 9 million + abortions since then. Abortion up to birth for 'serious disabilities' became legal in 1990 and the vague wording of the amendment has meant abortion for treatable conditions such as Club foot, cleft lip and cleft palate.

Keep reading
Back to school 2 4

Department for Education allows delay to RSE introduction

The Department for Education has written to schools in England, instructing them that they no longer have to begin teaching the new Relationships and Sex Education curriculum from September this year.

Keep reading
Shutterstock 171352904 0

Sign the letter calling on MPs to reject NI abortion regulations

MPs at Westminster are expected to debate the Northern Ireland abortion regulations on Monday 8 June with the vote happening soon after. Peers will debate and vote on the regulations, probably on 15 June.

Keep reading