CARE: Christian Action, Research and Education

For what you believe
Open menu Close menu

Former SNP deputy leader issues warning over new hate crime laws

Religious Liberty
22 May 2020
Scottish Parliament

The Scottish Government’s controversial new hate crime laws have been heavily criticised by a former Deputy Leader of the Scottish National Party (SNP).

Jim Sillars is a member of the SNP and was deputy leader from September 1991 until September 1992. He’s a prominent figure in the campaign for an independent Scotland.

Writing for the Spectator, Mr Sillars warns that the hate crime and public order bill would ‘divorce’ Scotland from the ‘heritage’ of people like Robert Burns and Adam Smith.

These historical figures gave Scotland a heritage where people were unafraid to and willing to ‘discuss, probe, dispute ideas and thoughts in the liberating realm of fearless free speech.’

Scots locked in a woke chamber’

Instead, Scots are ‘locked in a woke chamber: virtue signalling, pandering to perceived victimhood, punishing any for asserting biological fact, placing a halter of criminality on free thought when articulated by speech, abandoning common sense.’

The real problem with the new bill is that the state is trying to limit speech to what it deems acceptable, thus undermining freedom of thought and expression.

According to Mr Sillars, the new hate crime laws

casts its net wide both in terms of who can claim to be a victims and who can be caught.’ As such, ‘actors, directors, writers, promoters of plays better watch out and columnists, cartoonists, song writers, stand up comics and bloggers too.
Jim Sillars Former Deputy Leader of the SNP

Scot­land’s new blas­phemy laws

In a final, devastating critique, Sillars finishes by saying that while Ministers ‘boast of repealing old blasphemy laws’, they’re in fact ‘blind to creating new heresies for a new blasphemy law, much wider in its weep and more injurious to free thinking and free speech than the old one.’


Hands on Bible 0
Under the new laws, Christian views could be criminalised

The Scottish Government has introduced a new hate crime and public order bill. It aims to repeal old blasphemy laws in Scotland and create new hate crime offences.

It also expands the list of protected characteristics and Ministers will, by regulation, be able to expand it further should they wish to do so.

The legislation has already been heavily criticised. Tory MSP Murdo Fraser, for example, has warned that the new legislation is an assault on free speech and that MSPs will want to carefully scrutinise the new laws.

CARE’s view

CARE believes strongly in freedom of expression. While there are some welcome elements to the Bill, regarding free speech, it relies on hard to define terms. This will create chaos and confusion and likely undermine free speech. While curbing prejudice of any kind is right, hate crime laws run the risk of creating a new thought police, under whom Christians, for example, would find themselves criminalised for holding orthodox views on matters like sexuality.

CARE believes strongly in freedom of expression.
James Mildred Head of Communications

Receive news from CARE each week

By signing up stay in touch you agree to receive emails from CARE. You can change your mailing preferences at any time either by getting in touch with CARE, or through the links on any of our emails.

Recent news in Religious Liberty


Religious Liberty

The right to freedom of religion or belief is a fundamental human right. We are campaigning to safeguard these freedoms in our society.

Find out more about the cause