CARE: Christian Action, Research and Education

For what you believe
Open menu Close menu
Objection 9

Extreme abortion change in NI could leave health workers exposed

16 September 2019

Healthcare workers who conscientiously object to carrying out abortion procedures could be ‘exposed’ if the current law on abortion in NI is changed, a former midwife has warned.

Debbie Duncan, who lectures at the School of Nursing and Midwifery at Queen’s University in Belfast fears the changes will go too far and leave NI with little or no regulation.

In July, MPs and Peers fast-tracked radical changes to abortion law in NI by passing amendments to the Northern Ireland (Executive Formation) Act.

Healthcare workers could be left exposed

If the Northern Ireland Assembly is not restored in just 35 days’ time, abortion will become available in NI potentially up to 28 weeks or the point of viability.

This means NI’s life-affirming law, thanks to which 100,000 lives have been saved, will fundamentally change – leaving NI with a more permissive abortion regime than the rest of the UK.

If the Assembly is not restored by the 21 October deadline, the changes will come into force the very next day on October 22.

But regulations governing this extreme new abortion regime need only be in place by the end of March 2020, leaving NI with a 5-month ‘limbo period’ where there will be no regulation at all.

Many reasons to be alarmed

Ms Duncan, who worked for the NHS for 30 years said: “Most people would agree the 1861 Act needed to change, but the process should have taken longer and it should have gone out for consultation. These amendments may leave me and my health care colleagues exposed in Northern Ireland where there is no clause on conscientious objection.”

Under the 1967 Abortion Act, which applies in England, Wales and Scotland, midwives can conscientiously object if they so desire.

It is not the only area of concern. If the law on abortion in NI changes, it will be legal to abort on the basis of the baby’s gender, or in cases of disability. It constitutes a radical cultural change on abortion.

CARE’s response

Commenting, CARE’s communications manager, James Mildred said: “These valid concerns draw attention to yet another difficulty arising from Westminster’s decision to impose extreme abortion law changes on Northern Ireland.

“Even if you favour abortion being more widely available, surely all can agree that individual freedom and the right to conscientiously object should be respected?

“Northern Ireland faces entering into a dangerous legal vacuum when it comes to abortion law if the Assembly is not restored by 21 October.

“It is not right that such a profound social change should be imposed without any consultation with the people of NI.

“For this reason and so many others, the Assembly needs to be restored before it is too late.”

Find out more

Visit CARE NI’s Fearfully and Wonderfully Made campaign website for more detail



In any pregnancy, both the woman and preborn baby have inherent value and dignity, by virtue of being made in the image of God. CARE is passionately pro-woman and pro-life.

Find out more about the cause

Recent news

Pills Credit thanasus Shutterstock CNA

'Home Abortions: just a phone call or text away'.

Under the guise of the coronavirus lockdown abortion campaigners have taken the opportunity to lobby the UK Government to substantially change the rules around abortion pills, something they have been wanting to do for years, as this blog explains.

Keep reading
Modernslavery 0

Press release: New figures show sharp rise in the number of modern slavery referrals

The number of potential modern slavery victims referred to the UK’s National Referral Mechanism (NRM) rose sharply last year, according to the latest statistics published today.

Keep reading
Reproductive health supplies coalition F2b Tuiboieg unsplash

Northern Ireland: push to allow 'DIY at-home' abortions during Covid-19 pandemic

In recent days, the British Government alongside the Scottish and Welsh Governments have indicated they are going to allow women to take both abortion pills at home in response to pressure from lobby groups. These groups argue that this change is necessary due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

Keep reading