CARE: Christian Action, Research and Education

For what you believe
Open menu Close menu
Baby 2 B mums hands 1 6
Abortion

Woman launches landmark legal case over abortion guidance

5 May 2020

A woman is taking the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) to court in a bid to force abortion clinics to properly inform their patients that a baby may feel pain during an abortion.

Ana-Maria Tudor, 32, was initially delighted to discover she was pregnant, having previously been told this was unlikely due to a medical condition. She was however pressurised into having an abortion by her partner.

Following a minimal consultation, she had an abortion at 23-week gestation at the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS) in Richmond on 13 April 2017.

But she claims she was never actually told that her baby might feel pain during the procedure and she only found out after the termination that babies born at 23 weeks can survive outside the womb.

Abortion 1 0
Doctors even refused to show Ms Tudor the scans of her baby, despite her requesting to see them

Owing to this lack of critical information, she says she could not have given genuinely informed consent.

Ms Tudor told the Mail of Sunday:

‘I did not find out a baby at 23 weeks might be able to feel pain until afterwards. It made me feel awful and I now deeply regret my decision.’
Ana-Maria Tudor

Her solicitor, Paul Conrathe of Sinclairslaw said:

‘The failure to provide this information to my client meant she went ahead and aborted her baby at 23 weeks, a decision she profoundly regrets.’
Paul Conrathe

The case

Shutterstock 300750932 0 0
Lawyers are claiming current abortion guidance for clinics is unlawful and fails to provide all necessary information

According to the legal papers lodged by Ms Tudor’s lawyers, the challenge against NICE is that the current abortion guidelines (NG140 Abortion Care) fail to recommend that:

  • Women should be informed that their baby may suffer pain if aborted at 18 weeks or possibly earlier;
  • Pain relief should be given to any unborn child over 18 weeks old;
  • Women should be informed that babies born at 22 weeks can survive outside the womb.

In the letter sent to the NICE threatening a judicial review, Ms Tudor’s lawyers argue that the current guidance is unlawful because women cannot give informed consent without being told exactly what the abortion procedure will mean, with all its accompanying implications.

Two key issues

There are two key issues in this case. The first is the failure to advise that pain relief be administered and the second is the issue of viability.

The current law on abortion in Great Britain is the 1967 Abortion Act. Right now*, the time limit for most abortions is 24 weeks. When the 1967 Abortion Act was first passed into law, the time limit was 28 weeks, then in 1990, when abortion up to birth for disability was introduced, the time limit was changed to 24 weeks via an amendment to the '67 Act.

*(There is a disturbing campaign in Parliament to make the existing abortion law in Great Britain even worse. CARE's Naomi Marsden exposes what's really going on in the so called 'decriminalisation' of abortion movement.)

Viab­il­ity: can a 23 week year old baby sur­vive out­side the womb?

Shutterstock 78972478 0
Survival rates for premature babies have doubled in the last decade

The survival rate for extremely premature babies has doubled over the past decade. According to one expert neurologist, Professor John Wyatt, if a baby is born at 23 weeks in the UK and is given reasonable quality medical care from the moment of birth, the chances of survival would be approximately 50-70%.

In recognition that survival rates were improving, the British Association of Perinatal Medicine recently released new guidance recommending doctors try to save babies born at 22 weeks.

Pain relief: can unborn babies feel pain?

Baby holding mothers hand 6 0
There is growing evidence that unborn babies can feel pain from 18 weeks and possible before

This is an area of ongoing debate. However, there is growing evidence that babies as young as 18 weeks can feel pain.

Current guidance for abortion providers relies on a 2010 review by the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) into fetal awareness.

In that review, the RCOG state that a pre-born baby is in an unconscious state until birth, however, this was based on evidence from only one paper.

A more recent article published in the Journal for Medical Ethics suggests there is now ‘good evidence’ that the brain and nervous systems are sufficient from 12 weeks gestation for the baby to feel pain.

The All Party Pro-Life Parliamentary Group collected evidence on fetal sentience and pain only last month and it’s summary report is very critical of the current RCOG guidance.

That report concluded that:

‘The Review has highlighted significant areas of scientific, clinical and philosophical concern, and changes in clinical practice, which should lead the RCOG to review its 2010 guidance.’
Feotal senitence and pain: an evidence review All-Party Parliamentary Pro-Life Group

While the APPG’s report acknowledges different views on whether between 12 – 24 weeks gestation babies feel pain, it goes on to highlight additional evidence which suggests pain may be felt during that period.

CARE’s View

This is a landmark case. Ms Tudor is showing great courage in being willing to challenge the current consensus. More and more evidence is coming to light that only serve to highlight that our current abortion laws, far from being 'progressive' are in fact quite the opposite. It is striking to note that in Animal Welfare legislation - and the UK is seen as a world leader on this front - if there is a suspicion that an animal will feel pain, then the benefit of the doubt is given and pain relief is administered. In this, we treat animals better than unborn babies. We are praying that through this case, real change comes for the better.

Newborn baby mother 1
The womb should be the safest place for an unborn baby
Abort

Abortion

In any pregnancy, both the woman and preborn baby have inherent value and dignity, by virtue of being made in the image of God. CARE is passionately pro-woman and pro-life.

Find out more about the cause

Sign up for Impact Direct

We want to show a better story for our culture and society, and we want to help you be part of shaping that in structures that we are given as citizens in the UK.

Our weekly email, Impact Direct, is about helping you stay informed, up-to-date, and equipped to engage in culture and society.

Sign up now

Recent news

1993 care for life 3

Next two weeks will be crucial in the fight for life

The next two weeks are going to be critical in the fight for life. Since 1967, Great Britain has had a liberal and permissive abortion law and there has been 9 million + abortions since then. Abortion up to birth for 'serious disabilities' became legal in 1990 and the vague wording of the amendment has meant abortion for treatable conditions such as Club foot, cleft lip and cleft palate.

Keep reading
Back to school 2 4

Department for Education allows delay to RSE introduction

The Department for Education has written to schools in England, instructing them that they no longer have to begin teaching the new Relationships and Sex Education curriculum from September this year.

Keep reading
Shutterstock 171352904 0

Sign the letter calling on MPs to reject NI abortion regulations

MPs at Westminster are expected to debate the Northern Ireland abortion regulations on Monday 8 June with the vote happening soon after. Peers will debate and vote on the regulations, probably on 15 June.

Keep reading